Skip to content
For Magento, Shopify and WooCommerce stores, with Google Analytics and Meta AdsSee the use cases
Back to the journal
Sales

Do discount codes pay off?

A code used 900 times is not the same as a code that made money. How to work out what a discount costs, what the Coupons and Sales reports can tell you, and how to compare a promotion with a normal period.

Used is not the same as profitable

White Friday is coming, and the plan for last year’s code is already on the table: same code, bigger discount. It was used 900 times. That sounds like a success, and it may have been. It may also have given 20% off to customers who would have paid full price a week later.

A discount pays off when the extra orders it brings earn more than the margin it gives away on orders you would have had anyway. Counting uses does not answer that. Comparing a promotion period with a normal one, and knowing your margin, does.

What a discount costs per order

Illustrative example: a full-price order at Nile & Thread is EGP 800, and the products in it cost EGP 480, leaving EGP 320. With a 20% code the customer pays EGP 640 and the products still cost EGP 480, leaving EGP 160. The discount took a fifth of the price and half of the profit. To earn what 400 full-price orders earn, EGP 128,000, the store needs 800 discounted orders.

Free-shipping codes work the same way. On a cash-on-delivery order, the delivery fee you waive comes straight off the EGP 320, and it is still paid if the order is refused at the door.

Insights does not hold your product costs, so this part uses your own figures. What Insights adds is the actual behaviour: how many orders used a discount, what they were worth, and whether those customers came back.

What the Coupons report tells you

Coupons lists each code with its Type, Amount and Times Used, and charts the 15 most used. Times Used comes from your store platform’s own counter, so it is the code’s total use since it was created, not its use within the dates you selected. The report does not show revenue per code.

Use it to see which codes are live and how widely they spread. A code meant for one influencer’s followers that has been used 900 times has probably travelled further than planned.

Compare the promotion with a normal period

For the money, use Sales. Set the promotion dates as the main range, then choose Custom dates for the comparison and pick a normal stretch of the same length, away from holidays. Net Sales, Succeeded Orders, Avg. Order Value and Total Discounts show both periods side by side. The Discount Impact panel splits orders into With Discount and Without Discount, with Orders, Revenue, Avg Order Value and Completion Rate, the share of those orders that have reached Completed.

Back at Nile & Thread, a normal 10 days brings 400 full-price orders. The 10-day promotion brought 700: 500 With Discount at EGP 640 and 200 Without Discount at EGP 800. Net Sales rose from EGP 320,000 to EGP 480,000, up 50%. Using the per-order figures above, profit rose from EGP 128,000 to EGP 144,000, up 12.5%. If the 10 days after the promotion then run 100 orders below normal because customers bought early, that is EGP 32,000 of profit lost, more than the promotion added.

So check the period after the promotion too, with the same comparison. Read the cancellation rate in Order Lifecycle for the promotion dates as well: on cash on delivery, orders placed on impulse for a discount may be refused more often, and every refusal comes off the count above.

New buyers or regulars?

A promotion that brings new customers can pay back later, through their second and third orders. One that mostly discounts regulars moves their purchases earlier at a lower margin. On Overview, New Customers and Returning Customers show both periods side by side, and on Sales, New vs Returning Revenue splits revenue between first-time and repeat buyers. Two or three months later, open Cohort Analysis and check whether the promotion month’s cohort came back in M1 and M2 at the same rate as other months.

For a promotion aimed at new customers, write the target down before it starts: how many first orders, and what share of them should order again within two months. Then the cohort table tells you whether it worked, and the usage count stops being the measure.

Before the next promotion

Do this with last year’s promotion before you set this year’s discount.

  1. Coupons: list the codes that were used and check for any that spread further than planned.
  2. Sales: compare the promotion dates with a normal period of the same length using Custom dates, and read Discount Impact.
  3. Work out profit per order at full price and at the discount, using your own product costs.
  4. Sales: compare the days after the promotion with the same normal period to check for a dip.
  5. Overview and Cohort Analysis: check how many buyers were new and whether they came back.
  6. Set the discount at the level your margin can carry, not at last year’s level by default.
Explore more articlesCreate your workspace
Do discount codes pay off? · ignitix insights