Sales dropped: what to check before you change anything
A fall in net sales has four common causes: fewer visitors, fewer buyers, more cancellations or smaller baskets. How to tell which one you are dealing with, in the right order.
Four ways sales can fall
When the month closes lower than the last one, the first instinct is to do something: launch a discount, raise the ad budget, change the homepage. Each of those fixes a different problem, and picking the wrong one costs money twice, once for the fix and once for the problem that is still there.
Net sales is succeeded orders multiplied by average order value. Orders can fall because fewer people visited, because fewer of the visitors bought, or because more of the orders placed were cancelled before they counted. Average order value can fall because baskets got smaller, cheaper products took over, or discounts got deeper. Separating these takes four reports and about half an hour.
Split the gap into orders and order value
Illustrative example: Nile & Thread, a clothing store in Alexandria, closed October with Net Sales of EGP 420,000 against EGP 480,000 in September, a drop of 12.5%. September had 800 succeeded orders at an average of EGP 600. October had 750 at EGP 560. Fifty fewer orders at September’s average is EGP 30,000. EGP 40 less on each of October’s 750 orders is another EGP 30,000. Half the gap is order count and half is order value, so there are two causes to find, not one.
To get these figures, open Sales, set October as the range and choose Custom dates for the comparison, with 1 Sep to 30 Sep. Net Sales, Succeeded Orders and Avg. Order Value then show both months side by side. Previous period repeats the same number of days, which for a 31-day month starts on 31 Aug, so Custom dates is cleaner for calendar months.
Fewer orders made, or fewer orders kept?
Read the Order Lifecycle panel on Sales. Total Orders Made counts every order placed; Succeeded counts those in your net sale statuses; Cancelled/Refunded counts cancelled, refunded and partially refunded orders, with its rate. Orders still Pending or On Hold are in neither, so Succeeded and Cancelled/Refunded don’t always add up to Total Orders Made. If orders made fell, demand fell, and the answer is in traffic and conversion. If orders made held steady but fewer succeeded, demand is fine and the orders are being lost after checkout.
At Nile & Thread, orders made were 900 in both months. Cancelled/Refunded went from 60 (6.7%) to 110 (12.2%), and 40 orders were still Pending or On Hold in each month. The 50 missing orders are cancellations, not lost shoppers. The next stop is Cancellations, which ranks cities and products by cancellation rate.
Before trusting that, open Order Status Mapping in Settings and look for a raw status you do not recognise. A new status added by a plugin or a courier integration may be mapped to something that counts it as a sale when it should not, or the other way round.
Smaller baskets
For the order value half, stay on Sales. Order Value Distribution shows how many orders fell into each value band, so you can see whether large orders disappeared or every order got a little smaller. Average Basket Size Trend shows items per order by week. Discount Impact splits orders with and without a discount and shows the average order value of each.
Then open Products with the same comparison. If a product that usually carries high-value orders sold less, look for it under Out of Stock Products on Inventory. At Nile & Thread, the winter jacket that led September sold out on 9 Oct, and the cheaper items that filled the gap pulled the average down.
Fewer visitors, or fewer buyers?
When orders made fall, open Revenue Per Visitor for each month in turn. The marketing reports show one period at a time, so note Total Users, Total Sessions and Conversion Rate for both. Fewer users at the same conversion rate points to traffic: a paused campaign, a lost search ranking, a quieter month on social. The same users at a lower conversion rate points to the site or the offer.
Channel Conversion then shows which channel moved. If Paid Social sessions halved, open Ad Summary under Meta Ads and check whether spend changed. If the drop is spread evenly across channels, look at the calendar before anything else. Ramadan, Eid and White Friday move sales between weeks, and the Islamic holidays fall about 11 days earlier each year, so the same month last year may not be a fair comparison.
The checklist
Work through it in this order and stop when you find the cause. Fixing a cancellation problem with a discount, or a stock problem with more ad spend, makes the next month harder to read.
- On Sales, compare the two months with Custom dates and split the gap into order count and average order value.
- In Order Lifecycle, check whether Total Orders Made fell or only Succeeded did. If only Succeeded fell, open Cancellations.
- For order value, read Order Value Distribution, Average Basket Size Trend and Discount Impact, then check top products against Out of Stock Products on Inventory.
- For orders made, compare Total Users and Conversion Rate on Revenue Per Visitor for each month, then find the channel on Channel Conversion.
- Check Order Status Mapping in Settings for statuses you do not recognise before you share the numbers.